Decision: Government of NCT of Delhi v. M/s Ram Krishan Yudhister Prakash
Citation: FAO (COMM) 198/2026 | Delhi High Court, 31 October 2026
An arbitration clause is often invoked years after a public works contract is completed. In that interval, the identity of the appointing authority and the independence of the nominee can become as important as the monetary claim itself.
The dispute and its setting
The dispute arose from construction of Mohalla Clinics under a PWD contract. The department nominated a retired PWD officer as sole arbitrator. The tribunal made an award, and the department’s Section 34 challenge was dismissed. On appeal, the court examined the effect of unilateral appointment and Section 12(5) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
What the Court decided
The Division Bench held that participation in the arbitration did not, by itself, validate an appointment hit by the statutory disqualification. A valid waiver requires an express written agreement after disputes have arisen. The appellate court set aside both the award and the order that had refused to interfere with it.
Practical implications
Parties should retain the notice invoking arbitration, appointment correspondence, disclosures under Section 12, and any express post-dispute waiver. In construction contracts with government departments, the qualifications and relationship of the arbitrator to the appointing party require particular attention. A later challenge should not be reduced to objections about quantum if jurisdiction itself is questioned.
What the ruling does not decide
The ruling does not mean that every retired public employee is automatically disqualified in every arrangement. Eligibility depends on the statutory categories, the actual relationship and any legally effective waiver. The case illustrates why an award can fail at the level of constitution of the tribunal even before its findings are examined.
Judgment/source: Read the referenced decision or court summary.
Legal commentary for general information. The applicable law and relief depend on the facts and the procedural stage of each matter.
