Chat with us on WhatsApp!

Can One Party Choose the Arbitrator? The Supreme Court’s 2024 Constitution Bench Ruling

Judgment: Central Organisation for Railway Electrification v. ECI SPIC SMO MCML (JV), 2024 INSC 857 | Supreme Court Constitution Bench | 8 November 2024.

A commercial contract may provide that disputes will be decided by a sole arbitrator appointed by one contracting party, or by a tribunal chosen from a panel prepared by that party. The drafting may be common. Its fairness is another matter.

In November 2024, a five-judge Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court revisited the law governing unilateral appointments. The decision is especially significant for contractors dealing with public sector undertakings and government bodies.

The question before the Constitution Bench

Earlier rulings had emphasised the neutrality required in appointments. In TRF Ltd. v. Energo Engineering Projects Ltd. and Perkins Eastman Architects DPC v. HSCC (India) Ltd., the Court considered the position of an interested or ineligible person controlling the appointment of an arbitrator.

A different approach taken in earlier litigation involving the Central Organisation for Railway Electrification had generated uncertainty, particularly where one party maintained a panel and the other was required to choose from it.

What the majority decided

By a majority of three to two, the Constitution Bench held that a clause empowering one party to appoint a sole arbitrator unilaterally is impermissible. The majority also considered the unfairness of making one party choose an arbitrator from a panel curated exclusively by the other party.

The Court linked this conclusion to the requirements of independence, impartiality and equal treatment of parties. Equality is not an issue that begins only after an arbitral tribunal is constituted; the process by which the tribunal is selected matters too.

The Court did not say that a public sector undertaking is forbidden from maintaining a list of possible arbitrators. The problem arises when the procedure improperly gives one side controlling influence over who will decide the dispute.

Prospective application is crucial: the majority expressly directed that the law laid down in the reference would apply prospectively to appointments of arbitrators made after 8 November 2024, specifying that this direction applies to three-member tribunals. The Court did not declare every arbitration appointment made before the decision automatically void. Historic appointments must be tested against the law and procedural posture applicable to them.

Why this matters when drafting contracts

An arbitration clause should identify a constitution procedure that does not allow either party to dominate selection of the decision-maker. If the parties genuinely agree on a neutral process, or a neutral appointing institution is involved, the risk of a later appointment challenge is reduced.

For existing contracts, a party should read the precise clause and examine when and how the appointment was made. The legal effect of the judgment in an individual proceeding can depend on its procedural posture and applicable law.

A practical point for litigation

Objections to appointment are often raised under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, including provisions dealing with disclosure, ineligibility and appointment by the court. They should not be left to vague allegations of bias. The relevant contractual terms, appointment letters and any objections or waivers should be examined together.

The central lesson is that party autonomy in arbitration is important but cannot be separated from the requirement of a fair tribunal.

Official source: Supreme Court of India, 2024 landmark judgment summary (2024 INSC 857).

Related reading on this site

This is a commentary on the principles discussed by the Constitution Bench, not a substitute for reviewing the complete judgment and later case law.

Disclaimer

Rule 36 of the Bar Council of India Rules prohibits advocates from advertising or soliciting professional work, directly or indirectly. This website contains general, factual information about Conventus Law Offices, its location, the advocates associated with it, their qualifications and areas of practice.

By selecting “I AGREE”, you acknowledge that you are accessing this information of your own accord, solely for information and reference. The content is not intended as an advertisement, invitation or solicitation to engage legal services.

The material on this website does not constitute legal advice or a legal opinion. Accessing or using this website, including sending a message through it, does not by itself create an advocate–client relationship. No outcome in any legal matter is promised or guaranteed.

Any legal question should be assessed in the light of its particular facts and applicable law.